Linksys SRW224P switch? Fan Noise?

Have a question or want to start a discussion? Post it! No Registration Necessary.  Now with pictures!

Threaded View


Anyone else have one of the above switches?  Very nice feature set,
but the fans are driving me out of the room.  Anyone know how to
disassemble it?  I gotta do something about those fans...

Thanks!

Re: Linksys SRW224P switch? Fan Noise?


"William P.N. Smith" wrote:
 
Quoted text here. Click to load it

Do you mean SRW 2024?

Re: Linksys SRW224P switch? Fan Noise?


Quoted text here. Click to load it


No, but it looks like essentially the same product, plus or minus the
gigabit (2024 has, 224 doesn't) and PoE (224 has, 2024 doesn't).

Is the 2024 really noisy?  I probably wouldn't notice it in a machine
room, but this is the noisiest thing in my office, and that's where my
LAN terminates...

Re: Linksys SRW224P switch? Fan Noise?


I have a SRW224G4 here right now. I can touch the case by the
fan with my outstreached arm and I can't hear the fan.

Sounds <g> like it's broken.

I have had a similar switch with but with only 2x GBE ports
(sorry don't know the exact model)
on my desk in the past and it was quiet enough too.


Re: Linksys SRW224P switch? Fan Noise?


anybody43@hotmail.com wrote:
Quoted text here. Click to load it

I'd give them a holler, but I suspect it has to do with the extra 180W
of power supply to drive the PoE functions.

OK, to answer part of my own question, pull the front cover off (four
clips molded into the plastic top and bottom keep it in place) and
slide the top cover forward till it can lift off.

The three original fans are 40x40x20 mm:

ADDA
DC Brushless
Model AD0412HB-C51
12V, 0.15A

addausa.com sez they are (in the family of) 10.1CFM at 31.9dB/A

Plenty of room in the case for blowers and other cooling options.  

I've got some aftermarket 10.25CFM@23dB/A fans and some slot coolers
(32CFM@28dB/A) on order from CoolerGuys.com, I'll let you know what I
come up with.

Re: Linksys SRW224P switch? Fan Noise?


Quoted text here. Click to load it

I got three Sunon 40x40x20 KD1204PKB1 cans from
http://www.coolerguys.com/840556017837.html and dropped them in this
evening.  The box got a lot quieter, but it's still not silent.

The good news is that the 2-pin connectors on the board are a subset
of the 3-pin connectors on the new fans, so I was able to plug them in
without any adapters or wire splicing.

The bad news is that the fan 'brackets' are stamped metal pieces
welded to the case, and the tabs on them protrude into the front of
the fan blades.  A bit of work with a Dremel tool would probably quiet
it down a lot more, but the metal sawdust would probably destroy the
box, so I'm gonna try bending them out of the way or replacing them
with some slot coolers next time.

More news as it happens...  8*)

Re: Linksys SRW224P switch? Fan Noise?


William,

I have the same switch but my biggest noise problem is the Dell 1750 sitting
in my computer room.  It's basically a 12x16 drywalls room.  Sound just
bounces around, very loud.  Anyway, I'm curious of what you did thus far as
fans are concerned.

 Also, I have a strange issue with mine.  The first top 12 ports will not
come up if anything is plugged into it.  I get a link light however nothing
can communicate what so ever.  I havent' configured anything on it out of
the box, any idea why?

Chuck





Quoted text here. Click to load it



Re: Linksys SRW224P switch? Fan Noise?


Quoted text here. Click to load it

Mine drowns out my Apple XServe G5 that it's sitting on top of, even
with the new quieter fans.  Sometime in the next couple of weeks I
hope to find the time to bend the fan brackets out of the way of the
fan blades, I'll report back when I do.

[Of course, taking this device down for 'maintenance' means losing
half my LAN and all my phones, so it's non-trivial and has to be
scheduled for off-hours and performed as expiditiously as possibble.
I've got another one on order that I may fiddle with instead...]

Quoted text here. Click to load it

I'd call Linksys and get it fixed under warranty, mine doesn't seem to
care what's plugged in where.  This assumes you've got the latest
firmware and have reset it to factory defaults, as that's the first
thing Linksys will have you try...]

Re: Linksys SRW224P switch? Fan Noise?


I figured out the problem not long after sending that message.  For some
reason, ports 1-12 were set to non-tagging vlan vs port 13-24 were set to
tagged vlan 1.  I didn't see anything in the documentation about this
setting.  I'm trying to get quieter after-market fans for my Dell PE 1750,
any ideas who would sell them?



Quoted text here. Click to load it



Re: Linksys SRW224P switch? Fan Noise?


Quoted text here. Click to load it

Look at the physical fans that are in the machine now, and google for
them.  Find the noise and airflow specs.  Goto any number of places (I
had good luck at CoolerGuys.com) that you can find with Google and
look thru their line of similarly sized fans.  Get at least the
equivalent airflow, and the lowest noise possible.

Note that not all fan noise comes from the fan, I've had a couple of
recent incidences where a fan is placed so close to something else
that it makes a lot of wind noise on the intake.  Move things or get a
thinner fan to quiet that down a lot.

Lots of luck, it's a long and iterative process...

Re: Linksys SRW224P switch? Fan Noise?


Charles U Farley wrote:
Quoted text here. Click to load it
Try hanging some nice tapestries or curtains on the walls. They will
absorb a lot of sound. It's why the big box theaters hang them on the
side walls. To keep the sound from bouncing.

Site Timeline