Pogue Reviews: Love It or Not? Looking at iPad From 2 Angles [telecom]

open original image

Reviews: Love It or Not? Looking at iPad From 2 Angles

By DAVID POGUE March 31, 2010

In 10 years of reviewing tech products for The New York Times, I've never seen a product as polarizing as Apple's iPad, which arrives in stores on Saturday.

"This device is laughably absurd," goes a typical remark on a tech blog's comments board. "How can they expect anyone to get serious computer work done without a mouse?"

"This truly is a magical revolution," goes another. "I can't imagine why anyone will want to go back to using a mouse and keyboard once they've experienced Apple's visionary user interface!"

Those are some pretty confident critiques of the iPad - considering that their authors have never even tried it.

In any case, there's a pattern to these assessments.

The haters tend to be techies; the fans tend to be regular people. Therefore, no single write-up can serve both readerships adequately. There's but one solution: Write separate reviews for these two audiences.

Read the first one if you're a techie. (How do you know? Take this simple test. Do you use BitTorrent? Do you run Linux? Do you have more e-mail addresses than pants? You're a techie.)

Read the second review if you're anyone else.

...