TG-1, Honeywell Dialers, and Uplink - Help: Which one should I choose?

Nov 10, 2006 14 Replies

First reply

Roland

None of the above. Due to FCC changes those are going away. Since you have Ademco (Honeywell) might as well stick to AlarmNet-G.

Read the full reply
TG-1, Honeywell Dialers, and Uplink - Help: Which one should I choose? open original image

I'm currently searching for a new monitoring service and radio device. I currently have an Ademco Vista 10SE panel. Sometime back I switched from standard line-line service to VOIP. I know there are a few VOIP monitoring options on the market (i.e. NextAlarm). However, I'm not too sold on the reliability of my broadband network. Additionally, I want to keep my system functioning in the event of a cut line or power failure. I have spoken with a ton of monitoring companies and I have read read a bunch of forums; all have led to some good suggestions. I'm still at a crossroads, however. There are so many options on the market. That is why I decided to ask the experts here on this forum. The main devices I'm currently looking at include:


  1. Telguard TG-1 -
    formatting link
    . Honeywell AlarmNet-C replacement models 7845GSM & 7845i-GSM -
    formatting link
    . Uplink Digicell 1500 -
    formatting link
    I'm not too keen on the Uplink, as it only reports burglary and fire. The TG-1 seems to be more mature than the Honeywell product. On the flip side, I'm sure the Honeywell products have a ton of really cool features as a result. (I'm not to familiar with AlarmNet either.)

Here are my requirements:


  • Easy to install - I will be installing myself (most likely). However, I am open to getting help if this prevents me from finding the right system.
  • Full reporting ability - I want the ability to report panic, burglary, fire, etc..
  • Radio service - I am in search of a radio service as my primary means of connectivity. GSM, GPRS, SMS, etc...
  • Widely adopted - I'm looking for something that is compatible with most monitoring services. I don't want to be pigeon hold into a specific service.

I'm sure there are many other products that fit my needs outside of the ones I listed. I, by no means, consider myself an expert on this subject. I am only armed with the information I have found on the internet the last two days. Therefore, I am very green. Any help will greatly be appreciated.


- Keith



You are referring to the Sunset Clause, correct? I thought the AlarmNet-C was going away. I also thought the TG-1 replaced the TG100 which was an analog system.

formatting link

  1. It looks like the TG-1 is the answer to the FCC changes.
  2. Additionally, the Honeywell (Ademco) 7845GSM product fulfills the FCC obligation and it runs on the AlarmNet-G network.
  3. Lastly, I believe the AnyNET product from Uplink can send all signals, but I can't verify. There is little information about this system since it is so new:
    formatting link

Nope the TG-1 and Honeywell units are brand new GSM's, the only one obsolete is the Uplink

Telguard TG-1, TG-4, and TG-7 are GSM.

Nope- the AnyNet is far from obsolete!

Mark was referring to the Digicell 1500. Sounds like we are all in agreement that the following are new/FCC compatible devices:

  1. TG-1
  2. 7845GSM
  3. AnyNET

The question still remains: which one should I select for residential service? What makes one better than another? I saw some things about the 7845 where you can remotely config the device. Does this mean it gives you access to disable/enable (alarm.com functionality) or does it mean an installer can help with the initial configuration? I am leaning towards the TG-1 for the following reasons:

  • Seems to be a standard and widely used device
  • Monitoring companies tend to charge less for this service than the AlarmNet service (from 6 to 10 dollars more per month for AlarmNet service from quotes I have received)

However, I really d> Nope- the AnyNet is far from obsolete!

He mentioned the Uplink 1500 which IS obsolete

For the 10SE #1 or #2 will work

How will a diy'er buy any of these services anyway?

| > Nope- the AnyNet is far from obsolete! | | He mentioned the Uplink 1500 which IS obsolete | |

That's the million dollar question.

He never asked, so perhaps he has a way we don't know about. Perhaps he'll tell us.

You just have to make the right friends. Actually, there are a few monitoring companies that will help me out with the equipment.

You know the saying: if there is a will, there is a way.

- Keith

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required