I've lurked on this news group for sometime and i thought i should add my two cents. I'm a CCNA instructor for a local academy in Ireland. I see the ones that come through the class and do well in all the exams and then suddenly do crap in the practical. You can smell someone who doesnt know one end of a router from another a mile off. As part of the course i can weight exams differently. Typcally the practical exam will account for about 60% of the overall mark. My reasoning behind this is that if you walk on-site to a customer, he ain't going to give a shit if you can't name all 7 layers, however, if you are there putting a x-over cable into the wrong port, setting up the router wrong etc you're going to get your ass kicked off-site very quickly.
I'm there to make sure the students have the knowledge to go out and do the job. Case in point; student i had one year would not do any labs, however his marks were excellent, i asked him to do one end of semester exam, he said he didnt need to as he had done all the e-labs, anyway i managed to get him to do one lab. Once he had the cabling done, i pulled one cable out without him seeing me, 45mins later he was still messing around trying to get the port to come up. Thats the benifit of doing practical labs and not boot-camping it. You cannot learn troubleshooting skills from a book!
That's my rant for the day over!
Flames to the above address!
Regards,
Garrett