Re: Identity Theft: Big Enough to Steal Lawmakers' Attention

Warning: a major rant follows.

She recalls a Macy's representative calling to ask about a $2,400 bill > on her new store card. "I asked them, 'How could you open an account > in my name if I already have an account there?' "

Because I don't believe the store reps care.

No one at Carson Pirie Scott apparently gave a crap when someone showed up with my stolen drivers license (ok, lost, but then someone found it and left the state with it) and applied for a card.

I was living in Cleveland at the time, and had never lived further west than southwest Ohio. CPS, a Chicago-based chain, never had any Ohio stores except a few in Toledo which had closed years ago, and the only reason I even recognized the name when I got a letter from them was because they used to buy flooring supplies from my father.

It apparently meant nothing that the criminal trying to screw me was quite a ways from Ohio and attempting to get credit with an Ohio license.

Credit-freeze laws growing > One rising form of legislation, the one being considered here in > Massachusetts, allows consumers to freeze third-party access to their > credit reports.

That's a great idea and I hope someone ends up passing a federal law of that nature. It would give a lot of control back to the consumer.

While lauded by many consumer advocates, such measures hint at the > challenges of combatting ID theft. Opponents say such laws are > intrusive measures that clunk up business practices.

And I'd like to tell those people that they can kiss my ass. The only reason I wasn't completely screwed back in 1998 when I lost my DL was because my credit was terrible back then -- and I was never happier about that than when I found out that the idiot had stopped after applying for three department store cards.

Representatives from credit-card companies disagree that such steps > are needed. J.P. Morgan Chase, for example, has stated that > cardholders will not be contacted unless the firm believes they are > victims of, or highly susceptible to, fraud.

The banks can kiss my ass too, and I say that as a consumer AND a merchant. The merchants are the ones who lose money if there are chargebacks. Not the consumers, not on chargebacks -- they get their money back. Certainly not the banks. They get to charge more because now the merchant is "high-risk." Or if you're talking about American Express, well ... I got dumped by Amex after one chargeback. ONE. No recourse, couldn't dispute the chargeback, nothing.

Critics warn that such laws could hold unintended consequences for > consumers. > "This should be about meeting consumer expectations," said Eric > Ellman, director of government relations for the Consumer Data > Industry Association, testifying against credit-report freezes in > Massachusetts. In emergency situations where credit is crucial, frozen > reports would slow access to funds, he says.

Like what, Mr. Ellman? Gee whiz, can't the house or car purchase wait? Free clue, jerkoff ... it's not a life-or-death issue. There are no credit checks if you get into an accident and get Life-Flighted to the emergency rooms. Hospital ERs ARE REQUIRED TO ACCEPT PATIENTS. Just about everything else can wait.

In addition, obstacles to credit would deter companies from pushing > promotional deals, like 10 percent discount cards.


But state lawmakers were skeptical. "It seems there's a very > paternalistic theme to those comments, which is 'We know what's best > for consumers,'" said Massachusetts state Rep William M. Straus. > He said the issue should be turned over to the victims of ID theft: > "Would they trade a 10 percent discount from Sears for everything > they've been through?"

Bravissimo, State Representative Strauss! Someone who Gets It.

Steve Sobol, Professional Geek 888-480-4638 PGP: 0xE3AE35ED Company website:

formatting link
blog, resume, portfolio:
formatting link Snail: 22674 Motnocab Road, Apple Valley, CA 92307

[TELECOM Digest Editor's Note: I definitly feel consumers should have the absolute right to lock up their credit bureau files so _no one_ can see them. Your application for credit, along with your password, would serve as your permission for a business to look at and act upon your credit. There would be no more of these credit card promotions where cards are just sent out willy-nilly because some store or credit card company said 'you meet our criteria; do you want a card?' If I want a card I have to specifically ask for one. PAT]
Reply to
Steve Sobol
Loading thread data ... Forums website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.