Does anyone have any recommendations for MCUs? I started out looking at the Cisco products, the IP/VC 3511 and modular IP/VC 3540 (as our infrastructure is primarily Cisco), but I have since found that other H.323 MCUs may offer greater functionality. Other suggestions are the Codian 4200 MCU, Polycom MGC-25 and Tandberg MCU (which appears to accommodate PRI ISDN for H.320 dial-in without a separate gateway).
The ability to dial-out to conference participants, a video-based auto-attendant and the streaming of in-progress or recorded conferences would be useful. The MCU needs to support H.263-only endpoints and both continuous presence and voice-activated conferences.
Are there any comparative reviews of these vendors' MCUs?
- amount of interoperability problems with particular conferencing systems
- common protocol options (H.235,H.239,H.264,...) are always work in progress and may decrease with newer releases and increase with changes inthe endpoints
So I suggest to have a look on the conferencing systems involved too
I started out looking at
Cisco is a OEM of Radvision
Yes, nice for high performance IP-only self-running conferences poor web interface, but this may change ...
Polycom MGC-25 > older stuff, there is a new series available
Tandberg MCU (which appears to
you have to pay for a gateway anyway. Do you need ISDN ? Tandberg and Polycom are expensive and build for service providers mainly.
This requires a appropriate scheduling/web interface, Do you like to build a central service ? Fixed group of targets or arbitrary future customers ?
a video-based
I suggest to have a look on DST media, which is market leader in Asia (joined with Polycom last year)
DST`has a nice recorder unit offering playback on demand As DST is the direct competitor of Codian, I exspect Codian has a comparable solution :-)
Completing the list: Radvision VCON Both come with a software-only client VCON has the leading management system called MXM. This offeres user driven telephony-like switching, central management includes foreign endpoints too. (Tandberg and Polycom do support their own endpoints mainly)
If you find a free comparison survey of MCUs, please let me know :-) Paying for such infos is possible at
Cabling-Design.com Forums website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.