Re: Broadband Competition Must Surely be Working

My DSL circuit is carried on a wire-pair that is nearly 50 years old,

That's nice. But a lot of old loop plant was replaced, in whole or in part. The Bell Labs history talks extensively about the local loop and technological improvements made to it through the 1970s through the use of concentrators and the like. This newsgroup has had discussions of more modern technology.

There *IS* a third alternative. Separate the 'content' from the > 'delivery infrastructure'.

That brings back regulation. We broke up the Bell System to get away from regulation and to go to competition.

It is very common in the marketplace for providers to bundle services and products. Many times we take it for granted and never think about. For example, most supermarkets and shopping centers today (outside downtown) provide free parking. What that really is is that their cost of building and maintaining a parking lot is passed on to the customers. It's bundled in. They could lower their prices (slightly) if they made people pay to park instead. Sports arenas tend to charge people (and charge dearly) to park. Which one is a preferable system? Should the govt dictate to one or the other?

Many stores also sell their own house brand. If you like a particular house brand, you may only get it at the associated store, not at any other store. If you like WalMart's t-shirts, don't look for them at JCPenney. That's bundling.

In many cases, there is a blurred line between "content". Should every customer choose their own automobile tires and radio on a new car? Should an airline not provide those free magazines at the seats? Should a doctor's office not provide magazines in the waiting room? All of those are bundled services and supposedly could be isolated out.

So, if a telecom provider wants to bundle services, why shouldn't it?

Otherwise we're back to the Bell System and we must wait for the government to tell us what we may and may not have. As an example, the Bell System proposed its first cellular (called AMPS then) test system many years ago. It took the FCC over a YEAR to grant permission.

Reply to
hancock4
Loading thread data ...

Cabling-Design.com Forums website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.