Re: My Space Sues Colorado Man for Spamming

On Tue, 23 Jan 2007, Mark Crispin replied to TELECOM Digest Editor regards this subject:

The earmark of a crackpot is to accuse others of being "spam enablers". You know nothing about what I have done (and do on an ongoing basis) to fight spam. Yet you seem to have no compunction about flinging dung as if you were a chimpanzee at the zoo.

It may give you emotional satisfaction, but all you accomplish is to make people ignore you.

You should be glad that ICANN has no authority to do as you suggest. Not long ago, Illinos District Court judge Charles Kocoras ruled that UK anti-spam organization spamhaus.org was "under Illinois jurisdiction", ordered Spamhaus to pay David Linhardt (a notorious Chicago spammer) $11.7 million, and actually considered ordering ICANN to pull Spamhaus' DNS record. As ICANN stated in

"Even if ICANN were properly brought before the court in this matter, which ICANN has not been, ICANN cannot comply with any order requiring it to suspend or place a client hold on Spamhaus.org or any specific domain name because ICANN does not have either the ability or the authority to do so. Only the Internet registrar with whom the registrant has a contractual relationship -- and in certain instances the Internet registry -- can suspend an individual domain name."

If matters were otherwise, you might have the people who you "last laugh" turning around and getting court orders to have telecom-digest and/or comp.dcom.telecom deleted.

Never, ever, overlook the Law Of Unintended Consequences.

-- Mark --

does not emerge from voting, party politics, or public debate. Si vis pacem, para bellum.

read more and respond »

Posted 5 years ago by Mark Crispin in General Telecommunications Forum

Report misuse