Speed of cable vs. dsl vs T1?

Sep 28, 2005 32 Replies

The $29 price is for 12 months. I called Comcast and they confirmed that they have individuals who sell direct at that price. I thought it was odd because Comcast sells it at a higher price but they said that the direct sales people do have that offer. That's what got me interested.

Bob

And a HECK of a lot cheaper!

That depends on location. Here, cable is 3mbps/256kbps and DSL is 0/0...

There is a symmetrical service similar to ADSL, called HDSL, which can also be configured for the DS1 rate of 1.544 Mb/s. It's cheaper than a standard DS1, but probably more expensive than ADSL.

The quality of service will depend on your provider. Some are better than others. This applies to both cable and DSL. DSL also often has the potential problems of dealing with different companies for the cable pair and DSL service and the resulting finger pointing. Also, the amount of sharing also depends on your ISP. In the case of my cable access, the subnet mask is 255.255.255.0. This means that the DOCSIS channel is shared by less than 255 subscribers. On the otherhand, an ADSL system I was working on recently, two DS3s (2x 45 Mb/s) are shared by 448 lines.

So, all in all, you simply can't say cable or DSL is better, even though your personal experiences may say one or the other is superior.

Cable too.

I have DS1 and cable. From the cable co, their download speed is about 2-3 times that of my DS1. However, I can't get streaming audio from my favorite internet radio to play without rebuffering over the calble. Over the DS1, I can listen and still run my web servers, hosted sites, ssh to customers, and myriad other operations without having the stream rebuffer.

As for service, the DS1 had one problem due to squirrels chewing through the wires. It was repaired within a few hours and the DS1 is *monitored* by the provider. The cable, on the otherhand, can go out for days before a tech is dispatched and I have to call and deal with their inane support droids first before they'll acknowledge that there is a problem requiring a tech dispatch.

Also, and Nov. will mark the one year anniversary, the cable internet has had an issue that Optimum Off-line has yet to address. The fix is something they can easily fix but simply ignore the issue.

Using a finger dipped in purple ink, James Knott scribed:

Absolutely.

I'm on RoadRunner, and get excellent service if I have a problem (which is seldom).

The BEST I can do (with no guarantee) on DSL is 1.5mbps, vs my 8mbps cable.

That's because the closest PacBell DSLAM is over 14,000 feet from me, and I'm in a populous residential area in a major U.S. city!

Lumber Cartel (tinlc) #2063. Spam this account at your own risk.

This sig censored by the Office of Home and Land Insecurity...

Remove XYZ to email me

Hi Ron,

I just got off the phone from Comcast. They are running a special in our area that includes High Speed Internet, Digital Cable, HDTV, and a TiVo type setup with an 80 hour drive for $76/mo. for everything for 12 months, no contract.

That was too good to pass up so I am getting it.

Bob

What happens after the year is up ?

You go to the regular rate which is $106/mo. But if they don't have another deal, I'll shop for another wideband connection. I take my email address with me and I keep the same ISP. I just need the connectivity so I can move around.

Bob

Well I've got $45 cable for $30 a month for a year. At that time I'll likely switch to Dish.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required