Does this flip-open flappy dohickey actually do anything? (Netgear A6210)

Have a question or want to start a discussion? Post it! No Registration Necessary.  Now with pictures!

Threaded View
https://www.amazon.com/NETGEAR-AC1200-Wi-Fi-Adapter-A6210-100PAS/dp/B00MRVJY1G

Or is just for show and something to accidentally (or purposely)
break off?  I seem to get better reception with it closed and
sitting it's its dock.

-sw

Re: Does this flip-open flappy dohickey actually do anything? (Netgear A6210)
This is a multi-part message in MIME format.
--------------1DF4A2D4FB70F67D50BC300B
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding

On 7/24/20 10:24 PM, Sqwertz wrote:
Quoted text here. Click to load it
MRVJY1G
Without access to drawings for it, I'd assume that it's designed to be a
somewhat directional antenna that you'd point at the AP for optimal signa=
l.

It could be purely decorative, although that'd be a strange move, for a
company as large as Netgear, to pull.



--------------1DF4A2D4FB70F67D50BC300B
Content-Type: application/pgp-keys;
 name="pEpkey.asc"
Content-Transfer-Encoding
Content-Disposition: attachment;
 filename="pEpkey.asc"

-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
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3D
=3Dd5t3
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----

--------------1DF4A2D4FB70F67D50BC300B--

Re: Does this flip-open flappy dohickey actually do anything? (Netgear A6210)
On 7/24/20 11:24 PM, Sqwertz wrote:
Quoted text here. Click to load it

Maybe.


In radio (RF), there is the concept of polarization of antennas and the  
radio waves that they emit.

Many APs have rubber duck antennas that actually do have wire in them  
and said rubber duck antennas are depicted vertical, thus vertically  
polarizing them.  Having a similarly vertically polarized antenna on the  
other end, like the A6210, passes the basic conceptual sniff test.

That being said, I don't know how the high frequencies in 802.11  
(multiple GHz) react to polarization compared to lower frequences (Hz /  
kHz / MHz).  It may be that the wavelength of the multi-GHz frequency is  
short enough that the orientation doesn't make much difference.

Though, I have fixed WiFi problems by making sure that the rubber duck  
antennas were standing vertical many times in the past.

So, conceptually, I think the idea passes the sniff test.

The biggest question to me is if there is anything inside the flap or  
not.  I doubt that Netgear would have created it if it didn't do  
something to make it worth the effort.



--  
Grant. . . .
unix || die

Re: Does this flip-open flappy dohickey actually do anything? (Netgear A6210)
On Sat, 25 Jul 2020 00:41:36 -0600, Grant Taylor wrote:

Quoted text here. Click to load it

Exactly. I couldn't tell if there were wires/connection in the hinge
or not. Or if it was just some sort of a inert deflector.

But it worked great.  I got 200-210Mb up/down sustained on USB 2.0
ports with it open or closed. But it started crapping out and
disconnecting after 10-12 hours.

Great product! If it would have worked.

-sw

Re: Does this flip-open flappy dohickey actually do anything? (Netgear A6210)
wrote:

Quoted text here. Click to load it

Netgear claims it does "beam forming" which means that it mangles the
antenna pattern for more gain in the desired direction, and less gain
in the direction of interference sources.  In order to do that, there
has to be at least 2 antennas and 2 radios involved.  I'm too lazy to
check the FCC ID web site to see if they have a photo of what's
inside.  My guess is the minimum, which means either one or more chip
or PCB antennas on the same board as the electronics and one or two
coaxial antennas in the flip out antenna thing.  This is a common
approach that barely works with such minimal spacing between antennas.
However, putting one horizontal antenna in the base electronics, and
the other mounted vertically in the flip out part give polarization
diversity in some directions.  That might be worth something if you
use the radio in a highly reflective environment.

The data sheet says 866 Mbit/sec maximum speed.  You can achieve that
speed with either 1 or 2 antennas at each end of the link depending on
the occupied RF bandwidth (80 or 160MHz).  See table:
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.11ac#Example_configurations
So, I have no clue if there are 1 or 2 antennas inside, but I'm fairly
sure that there are no more than two or the maximum rates would have
been higher.

For testing:
Setup a fast computah, with USB 3.0 for the adapter.  Find an 802.11ac
wireless router.  Attach a fast desktop running gigabit ethernet.  Run
iPerf3 on both machines:
<https://iperf.fr/iperf-download.php
Run the test using TCP (not UDP) using parameters tweaked for gigabit.
If you're not sure, lose the wireless temporarily and try iperf3 via
gigabit ethernet between the computers trough the ethernet ports on
the router.  You should get over 800 Mbits/sec.  Do it anyway.  It's
good practice.  

Ok, back to wireless.  Depending on the maximum throughput you should
be able to guess which configuration your wireless thing is using at
802.11ac from this table:
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.11ac#Example_configurations
You may need to temporarily disable 2.4GHz in the Netgear dongle or
the wireless router to prevent 2.4GHz traffic from mangling the
results.

Hmmm... reviews don't look so good on Netgears web pile:
<https://www.netgear.com/home/products/networking/wifi-adapters/a6210.aspx
11 out of 21 say it sucks.  Boiler plate replies from Netgear
"support".  Caveat emptor.
--  
Jeff Liebermann     jeffl@cruzio.com
150 Felker St #D    http://www.LearnByDestroying.com
Santa Cruz CA 95060 http://802.11junk.com
Skype: JeffLiebermann     AE6KS    831-336-2558

Re: Does this flip-open flappy dohickey actually do anything? (Netgear A6210)

Quoted text here. Click to load it

Thanks, Jeff.

Yeah, I mangled tiny little my AC6100 by double-sided sticky tape to
the wall.  And when I had to reposition it, it stuck a little too
well and popped off in a 5 different pieces. So I ordered this one
late at night for next day delivery VIA Amazon based solely on the
Amazon reviews.

I didn't see the Netgear reviews until it started crapping out on
me. For the first 12 hours it work GREAT! I was getting 210MB
up/down through a few walls and my central A/C unit in the middle
(runs all day in Texas), but then it started disconnecting every
time I ran a speed test or gave a load. I tested a few drivers and
read the reviews, and boxed it back up.

So it's on it's way back to Amazon and I got this cheapo TP-Link in
the meantime that can only sustain 1/4th of thee speeds of the
Netgear model:  

https://www.amazon.com/Wireless-desktop-10-9-10-14-Archer-T2U/dp/B07P5PRK7J/

So I'm still shopping for a dongle that can came close to 150Mb with
better than a 30min MTBF.  Not that really need 150Mb. I'm still
stuck in the 90's "download and store" rather than "stream all that
shit" mode.  I should also note that I have 15 and 25 feet of
braided USB cables running across the loft ceiling which I often use
as "range extenders". Heh.  My Google Fiber router can't be moved
for other technical reasons.

Thanks again, and Cheers!

-sw

Re: Does this flip-open flappy dohickey actually do anything? (Netgear A6210)
wrote:

Quoted text here. Click to load it

I don't know what the USB cables are about, but if you can run USB cables
why not run Ethernet cable through the loft? If you must remain wireless,
bring Ethernet over to where the PC is and terminate it with an access
point. Of course, if you go that far you might consider running Ethernet
down to the PC and be done with it.


Re: Does this flip-open flappy dohickey actually do anything? (Netgear A6210)
On Sat, 25 Jul 2020 11:36:30 -0700, Jeff Liebermann wrote:

Quoted text here. Click to load it

C'mon - I've seen your office and I know you can set this up with a
just a cable change. But I'm still limping along with my 20-year old
Antec case which I pilfered from the SCO Attic and an M4A87XD/USB3
motherboard. And just last week I upgraded to a Phenom II X4 945
(from Athlon II X2 255).

If I was still in scruz I would gladly have donated this to you for
disection rather then returning to Amazon :-)  But it looks like it
is/was a short-lived product - not worth investigating.  Most people
are blaming the drivers <shrug>.  Sounds like a job for
Arnet/Digiboard Bill!

-sw

Re: Does this flip-open flappy dohickey actually do anything? (Netgear A6210)
wrote:

Quoted text here. Click to load it


I've been in the process of shutting down my formerly palatial office
for the last year.  Business has been break even for the last 2 years.
The only thing that was keeping me there was the lack of any place to
put all the junk at my house in Ben Lomond.  Getting sick last year
(multiple kidney stones), and an inconveniently timed pandemic,
interrupted the move.  I'm currently about 90% out of the office and
"working" from home.  I could easily setup a iperf3 speed test at
home, if I could find the necessary computahs, parts, pieces, etc.
Right now, the workbench is buried in chain saw parts, while the
alternate workbench (formerly known as the dining room table) is
buried in boxes of junk.  I consider my desk and computer area to be
sacred ground, not to be tread upon or misused for such mundane tasks
as performance testing.  Please setup an iperf3 speed test and learn
how it works so that the next time you buy some wireless gizmo, you'll
have a clue how to test them.

Incidentally, there are a few internet iperf test sites:
<https://iperf.fr/iperf-servers.php

Quoted text here. Click to load it

No sympathy.  When I upgrade a customer, I usually buy or trade for
the old equipment.  Most of the stuff is at least 6 years old.  I keep
dreaming of buying a Rizen 4000 series system (when they come out) for
gaming.  I'm also currently stuck with a 1.2Mbit/sec ADSL internet
which is good enough for YouTube and Netflakes in 720i, but not much
else.  Linux and Windoze 10 installs are painfully slow. Incidentally,
when I semi-retire, my working machines will be running Linux Mint
Cinnamon where Windoze 7 and 10 will relegated to running under
Virtual Box.

Quoted text here. Click to load it

Please.  No new projects until after I move out of the office, clean
up the mess at the house, and take a short vacation from reality.

Good luck with the A6210.  I suggest wrapping it in bubble pack so
that it has a chance of passing your drop test.  Also, I use and
resell quite a bit of stuff from TP-Link.  The stuff looks shoddy, but
generally seems well designed inside.  I would buy TP-Link over
Netgear, which has the irritating habit of dying prematurely and often
without any warning.  Bulging electrolytic caps and dead power
supplies are still common.

--  
Jeff Liebermann     jeffl@cruzio.com
150 Felker St #D    http://www.LearnByDestroying.com
Santa Cruz CA 95060 http://802.11junk.com
Skype: JeffLiebermann     AE6KS    831-336-2558

Site Timeline