1. Home
  2. General Telecommunications Forum
  3. Foreign Airlines Ahead of U.S. on Cellphone Use [Telecom]

Foreign Airlines Ahead of U.S. on Cellphone Use [Telecom]

Foreign Airlines Ahead of U.S. on Cellphone Use

By JOE SHARKEY September 29, 2009

Cellphone use on airplanes, it would seem, is on extended hold in the United States.

The national union representing flight attendants wants Congress to ban in-flight phone calls, and survey after survey of airline passengers shows strong opposition to allowing cellphones on planes.

So while domestic airlines rush to wire their cabins to provide in-flight Wi-Fi connectivity, there is no indication whether, or when, passengers in the United States might be able to make a cellphone call at 37,000 feet.

In much of the rest of the world, meanwhile, passengers on various foreign airlines are already routinely using cellphones and other personal wireless devices to make and receive calls in flight. Industry officials say cellphones can be used on more than 15,000 flights a month.

Despite dire warnings that cellphone use on planes would unleash social turbulence and possibly even violence in the cabin, there have been remarkably few complaints so far, industry executives and passengers say.

...

formatting link

Reply to
Monty Solomon
Loading thread data ...

Good idea. On trains the cellphones are a nuisance. People talk loudly, sharing their most private personal or business affairs to unwilling listeners nearby.

On airplane, which has much denser seating and lower ceilings than a commuter train, the situation would be even worse.

If an argument breaks out among passengers on a commuter train the next station isn't too far away where help can be obtained. But on an airplane that isn't the case, plus it could be a major safety hazard.

When mobile phones on trains first came out in 1948, an enclosed booth with seat and table was provided for the privacy of the caller and courtesy to other passengers, this practice continued up to the Metroliner trains in 1969. Newer trains that had mobile phones didn't have a full booth, but the phone was at the end of the car somewhat away from other passengers.

Unfortunately, airplanes are so squeezed for space they simply can't afford to waste a few seats to put in a phone booth or even a nook. Further, while train passengers can get up and move around at any time during their trip, airplane passengers need to stay seated as much as possible, and can not get up during takeoffs, landings, and turbulent weather.

As an aside, Western Union hoped to be a player in airplane phone service with "airfone" and other business partners. WU eventually sold its interest in this effort. (WU also sought to be a conventional cell phone provider, another effort that did not work out.)

Reply to
hancock4

You might think so, but planes are so noisy that it turns out that you can barely hear somone talking on the phone in the next seat. I read an article about experience on planes in Europe and Asia, and that was my experience the one or two times I tried to use Airfone.

I'm not a big fan of phones on planes, since it's one of the few places where one is not on an electronic leash, but the noise argument is bogus.

R's, John

Reply to
John Levine

Cabling-Design.com Forums website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.