Computer Hardware Re: SATA II Harddisks ?

Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
Re: SATA II Harddisks ? Skybuck Flying 07-04-05
Posted by Skybuck Flying on July 4, 2005, 2:38 am
Please log in for more thread options

> Well I have compared the amd athlon x2 processor + nvidia nforce 4 chipset
> vs the intel pentium 4 extreme edition + intel 955x chipset.
>
> I have looked at benchmarks, features, software optimization guides and
> manuals.
>
> In general I like the athlon x2 and nvidia nforce 4 chipset a lot and here
> is why :)
>
> 1. Bios voice stuff:
>
> The coolest thing is the "bios voice reporter stuff".
>
> For example when the keyboard is not plugged in and the voice stuff is
> enabled it will say with a human voice: "no keyboard plugged in" or
> something like that.
>
> There is even a boot option so everytime you boot it says:
>
> "booting computer" or something like that.
>
> It's even possible to replace these voice message with your own voice
which
> could be lot's of fun everytime you start your pc.
>
> I could say something like: "welcome skybuck" :)
>
> Anyway that's just way cool and I want to see it in action ;)
>
> 2. Best performance in AMD/NVidia 4 corner occording to many websites...
> which is not too surprising looking at the facts/theory:
>
> Athlon x2 4800+ fastest... occording to benchmarks.
>
> Theory:
>
> SLI can support two graphics cards.
>
> DDR memory has lower latency than DDRII memory.
>
> Athlon X2 has onboard memory controller halving the latency even further.
>
> 3. Software optimization guide...
>
> AMD's software optimization guide was clear, short and straight to the
> point...
>
> However it didn't go into the multi threading stuff that much etc...
>
> Intel looked at it from a little bit higher view... focusing more on
> threading and cache stuff etc...
> The general impression was that software would have to be optimized a lot
> for the intel processor to achieve more performance which might be a
little
> bit too much to ask for programmers etc... In the end the software has to
be
> able to run on AMD and INTEL processors as well as possible. Though intel
> did provide some very interesting examples for 3d engines etc... ;)
>
> So in short AMD's software optimization guide was pretty simple and easy
to
> follow but I also kinda liked the intel software optimization guide ;)
> though a bit more complex and harder to follow ;)
>
> What I don't like about intel stuff is the following stuff:
>
> - No cool bios voice stuff.. just the normal (pretty stupid beeping :))
> which is a big turn off for me lol :D... zero innovation ;)
>
> - Much higher power/watt/ampere requirements etc... more expensive for
> electril bill and needs big expensive power unit...
>
> Though intel has some little points going (possibly)
>
> + 8 GB ram support (but no 2 GB ram chips available ?)
> + SATA II support (nvidia nforce 4 is only sata I support ?)
> + Asus is using passive cooling for some chips... (not sure what nvidia
> nforce 4 boards are using ?)
>
> This last point is something I am definetly going to look further into
> because I just fucking hate cooling fans since they attract lot's of dust
> and make noise etc... I fucking hate em ;)
> I live in a very dustry environment ;)
>
> Though I never cleaned my pentium III cooling fan and it's still working
> after 5 years which is pretty amazing... I did blow off some dust
sometime.
> My power fan having has to be cleaned at least once in two years etc.
>
> So I wonder if any cooling fans are sleave or ball bearing... The sleave
> bearing fans are probably worse because dust can get inside of them... the
> cpu fan is probably a ball bearing fan which probably explains why it is
> still going strong ;)
>
> However having everything passively cooled invokes fear inside of me...
fear
> that not enough air flow is inside the motherboard... heat building up and
> chips dieing ;) I do have a fanless video card (fx5200) and it's still
> working... it too is passively cooled.
>
> The biggest drawback for AMD/Athlon x2 4800+ is the bios problem... a
flash
> is needed.
>
> + So having a intel motherboard which works right out of the box which is
> available too is a big plus ;)
>
> + Also the intel motherboard supports DDR2 memory... will this is slower
it
> is the future of memory chips so probably not much to worry about
> availability of those chips.. However I plan to buy as much memory as
> possible so for me it's not a problem... unless the chips die in the
future
> ;)
>
> So the asus intel motherboards have some strong points going for them ;)
> (P5WD2 Premium (asus/intel/intel) vs A8N-SLI deluxe (asus/amd/nvidia) )
>
> 1. Immediate availability of motherboard and processor right out of the
box.
> 2. Passive cooling of motherboard chips. (I think the processor still has
a
> fan which might be good for a little bit of airflow ? However passive
> cooling for the cpu might be very impressive too ;) )
> 3. DDR II memory chips (slower but the future)
> 4. SATA II support
> 5. Possibly 8 GB ram support ? I expect 4 GB of ram to be enough for the
> coming 5 years. The pc will probably last 5 years... then it would need
> replacing to keep up with the games ;)
> (Within a year I expect the minimum ammount of ram to be 1GB for
longhorn...
> even 2 GB for gaming... then slowly it will go up to 4 GB after a couple
of
> years ;) ) so I think 8 GB of ram could be too much for the coming 5 years
> ;) however... it never hurts to have extra memory ;)
> 6. Better realtek codec 882d high definition (audio)
>
> I am a little bit worried about the AI NOS feature... it will
automatically
> overclock the system if a game needs more performance... I am worried
about
> overheating or crashes...

Hmmm this feature can be disabled which makes me feel all cousy and warm
inside =D

http://www.hardocp.com/article.html?art=Nzg2

Now I like this feature since this could even give more gaming performance
?!! hmmmm... going to read this review some more ;)

See you..


>
> Well it's a though decision...
>
> There is one more thing ofcourse... the intel pentium 4 extreme processor
> acts like 4 cpu's... which could be better in case windows xp 64 bit has
> many threads running at once... hyper threading tries to use parts of a
> processor which are not used by other threads ;)
>
> On one hand we have this overheating nvidia nforce 4 sli chip... but maybe
> it only overheats with two graphics cards... but a cooler athlon x2
> processor ?
> at least it uses less power...
>
> On the other hand we have this cooler intel chipset ?? passively cool...
> which could get a bit hotter but ok... but also a pretty hot power
consuming
> processor ? ;) hmmmmmmmmm. Which requires a power consuming psu which also
> could get quit hot... hmmmmmmmmm... :)
>
> If asus would come out with a new motherboard which would support the
athlon
> x2 processor out of the box and maybe with passive cooling for the
> chipsets... then I would be sold ;) and go for it =D add in 8 GB of ram
> support and maybe sata II support <- but maybe that s not possible with
> nvidia nforce 4 chipset... and it s even a better deal ;) oh yeah and
> ofcourse the better realtek audio.. however I will probably get an
> additional sound card for extra fps or maybe not =D
>
> The biggest problem is I want to build my own system and have all brand
new
> components in a sealed package... I do not want to buy used components
etc,
> which might be malfunctioning etc ;)
>
> (maybe the intel raid controller is better too... who knows ;) but I am
not
> that interested in raid ;) the biggest frustration is the limited i/o
> operations of harddisk in general... raid won't help that much... so I'll
go
> with seperate harddisk and a page file on a seperate harddisk ;) and
> ofcourse windows software tweaks ;))
>
> However I might give raid 0 a try just for kicks to see the transfer speed
> etc... maybe to store games on it for faster load times... but the
harddisk
> might not be the problem... maybe it's the decompressing of zip files
etc...
> which means cpu limited etc ;) :)
>
> Bye,
> Skybuck.
>
> > They surely will sell the same board with the latest BIOS installed.
> >
> >
> > da98ia$puc$1@news3.zwoll1.ov.home.nl...
> > >
> > >> >
> > >> > It also has 4 sata connectors so I guess that is at least room for
6
> > >> > harddrives ?
> > >>
> > >> Each IDE connector can handle 2 drives (master and slave).
> > >>
> > >> > I am not sure if the sata raid connectors can be used as normal
sata
> > >> > connectors ?
> > >>
> > >> They are not RAID connectors, the are SATA connectors. RAID is a
> > >> configuration, not a drive connection type.
> > >>
> > >> > What if I dont want to use raid ?
> > >>
> > >> No problem.
> > >>
> > >> > One last question about this board...
> > >> >
> > >> > What is the default bios version ? I would like to buy/use this
board
> > > with
> > >> > athlon x2 processor... I dont have any other processors... so
> flashing
> > > the
> > >> > bios is not an option for me ;)
> > >>
> > >> If you want the X2 you need to purchase the board and CPU from a
> reatiler
> > >> that will flash the bios with the lastest version or you will be dead
> in
> > > the
> > >> water.Moarch Computer is one vendor who will do this if you ask them
> to.
> > >> http://www.monarchcomputer.com
> > >
> > > Hmm I was thinking about buying all parts seperatly so that I can
check
> if
> > > all parts are new etc... by looking if all packages are closed etc. In
> > > other
> > > words I dont want anybody else to mess with my new stuff :)
> > >
> > > How long before asus ships a new motherboard that supports athlon x2
> > > processors out of the box... that's what I am wondering about =D
> > >
> > > Bye,
> > > Skybuck.
> > >
> > >
> >
> >
>
>




Similar ThreadsPosted
SATA II Harddisks ? July 3, 2005, 4:28 pm
Re: SATA II Harddisks ? July 3, 2005, 4:36 pm
Re: SATA II Harddisks ? July 4, 2005, 2:38 am
RPM mismatch of Harddisks November 17, 2005, 2:34 am
External casing for two or more harddisks. September 22, 2005, 11:37 pm
Harddisks mailfunction after being stored for a long while July 4, 2008, 7:01 am
Clevo D900T problem with 100GB harddisks. September 10, 2005, 3:26 am
Best SATA drive setup? Use ICH9R or Gigabyte SATA Controller? January 1, 2008, 9:38 pm
Availability of SATA 15-pin SATA power cable on each end September 20, 2005, 12:00 pm
do sata I drive work in sata II boards? June 6, 2007, 5:17 pm
Is SATA II backwards compat with SATA? June 5, 2005, 12:43 pm
SATA Internal vs SATA External June 20, 2007, 5:39 pm
SATA on SATA II Motherboard September 12, 2005, 10:30 pm
What is the difference between SATA II and SATA 2.5? March 31, 2006, 12:41 pm
SATA Help, Please July 18, 2005, 7:06 am