Have a question or want to start a discussion? Post it! No Registration Necessary.
Now with pictures!
Subject
- Posted on
January 21, 2007, 5:27 pm

I have little experience in expanding networks. Wondering whether if I can
expand an existing 100Mbps network comprising of two fast Ethernet switches
placed about 60m apart.
What I need to do is connect a couple of workstations residing in another
building which is about 90m from one of the existing switches. Is it
possible to run a cat6 from the switch to the new building and install
another switch there?
TIA

Re: Newbie question: How many switches can I install 100m apart?
Gerard Bok wrote:

802.1d says (or did at one time) that the limit is 7 hops.
You are proposing 3 hops so are well within those limits.
So it's Ok. (and advisable too).
There seems to be the idea that this 7 hop limit may not
be such an issue with modern equipment however it's not
what the standard says.
The 7 hop limit was expected to include thinks like 64k WAN
links and CPUs are now orders of magnitude faster.
If you are running cable put in more than one.

Re: Newbie question: How many switches can I install 100m apart?
On 21 Jan 2007 15:23:18 -0800 Bod43@hotmail.co.uk wrote:

It is basically not that much a hard limit but a recommendation, so that
the STP topology information cached in the switches does not time out in an
unreasonably short time (or even before the STP BPDU actually would have
arrived). Aside from that, it would actually require to have the 802.1d
Spanning Tree implemented *and* activated to fall under this guideline.
When using RSTP (which is far more common now) or when you know what you
are doing (and are able to set your own max_age), you will not be affected.

It actually does not have any relation to round trip times of your links or
the processing power of your switches. The trouble is, that the "message
age" of a BPDU is increased by one at each bridge. And the sum value of the
message age is subtracted from the max_age (which will be 20 seconds in
most defaults) when building topology information.
--
Denis Jedig
syneticon networks GbR http://syneticon.net/service /

Re: Newbie question: How many switches can I install 100m apart?
On 21 Jan 2007 15:23:18 -0800, Bod43@hotmail.co.uk wrote:

I'm far to lasy to read 802.1d, but I recall a 3-4-5 rule :-)

Read back in this newsgroup: from an ethernet point of view,
there is no problem at all.
From a 'cabling', 'safety' and 'regulatory' point of view it is
not advisable --or even prohibited-- to run such a length of
copper between 2 buildings.
--
Kind regards,
Gerard Bok

Re: Newbie question: How many switches can I install 100m apart?
On Mon, 22 Jan 2007 00:59:06 GMT Gerard Bok wrote:

There is no such rule in any of the standards. It used to be a "safe"
guideline for nowdays rather antiquated equipment to stay within the
boundaries of maximum propagation delays prescribed by the Ethernet
standards. However, as switched networks separate collision domains, it
absolutely does not apply here.

There is nothing in the standards that restrains you from having a 90m
link. Actually, you might have a working unrepeated 150m copper link
operating over standard ethernet equipment, if you get it right. Anything
longer than 90m however would be outside of the structured cabling
standards defined in the ISO/IEC IS 11801 or TIA/EIA 568 respectively.
While it is true that interbuilding links might (and often enough will)
introduce problems with equalizing current between the two linked points,
such links may as well work stable for years, even despite of lightning
strikes.
--
Denis Jedig
syneticon networks GbR http://syneticon.net/service /

Maybe wireless Re: Newbie question: How many switches can I install 100m apart?
Robert Redelmeier wrote:

Quite
You just need switches with fiber uplinks.
But as its "just a couple of pc's" you might find a wireless bridge
cheaper than
having to get fiber pulled - esp if you don't own the land between.

Re: Maybe wireless Re: Newbie question: How many switches can I install 100m apart?

as long as there is some glass between the 2 buildings you should be fine.

it may be cheaper to use copper and accept the risk that equipment gets
damaged?

Or use DSL modems if you have phone quality copper between the 2? Again -
may still get damaged.

--
Regards
stephen_hope@xyzworld.com - replace xyz with ntl
Site Timeline
- » How does Allied Telesis CentreCOM TM AT-210T and AT-210TS Micro Transceiver work
- — Next thread in » Ethernet LAN
-
- » Connecting two routers in home environment
- — Previous thread in » Ethernet LAN
-
- » NYC local event: UNIGROUP meeting Thur 16-MAR-2017: DataCenter Structured ...
- — Newest thread in » Ethernet LAN
-
- » How does Allied Telesis CentreCOM TM AT-210T and AT-210TS Micro Transceiver work
- — Last Updated thread in » Ethernet LAN
-
- » What Every Company Needs To Know About Business VoIP And Unified Communications
- — The site's Newest Thread. Posted in » Voice-Over-IP
-