Difference between Ethernet 2 and 802.3 Frame per the Ethernet FAQ
Bookmark this page:
 Yahoo!
 Google
 Windows Live
 del.icio.us
 digg
 Netscape
|
|
||||||||||||||||
|
Posted by newbie123 on July 28, 2006, 9:02 am
Please log in for more thread options Hi All, This question is probably trivial to everyone else but I am unable to understand so please don't flame just in case. Per the Ethernet FAQ it states that the difference between the frame types is: "In the 802.3 frame type, this two-byte field after the source address is a length field specifying the number of bytes in the LLC and data fields. If these two bytes are greater than 05DC hex (1500 decimal), the frame is a Version 2 frame. Since all type fields are greater than 1500 decimal (the maximum Ethernet frame size), both frame types can easily coexist on the same network" Now in the Ethernet 2 Frame the type field is 2 bytes and since I believe that is the most common format on most LAN's we see eg: 0800 (Hex) for ip. But per the statement quoted above it says that in the 802.3 header the length field specifies the number of bytes in the LLC + in the Data field. Now the LLC header I think is the SSAP and the DSAP which are 1 byte each but adding the Data portion would be well over the 2 bytes. Confused as to how it would store this. Another question related to the same frame type is that in the FAQ and other places it gives 4 frame formats. Now when it says difference between Ethernet 2 and 802.3 is it referring to the 802.3 novell 'raw' or to the combination of the 802.2 LLC and the 802.2 SNAP frame type. Thank you for your help | ||||||||||||||||
|
Posted by Walter Roberson on July 28, 2006, 9:32 am
Please log in for more thread options In other words, if the field is up to 1500 then this frame is a 802.3 frame, and the field is a length for the rest of the frame. If the filed is more than 1500 then the frame is an 802.2 frame and the field has frame type information instead of a length. >Now in the Ethernet 2 Frame the type field is 2 bytes and since I
>believe that is the most common format on most LAN's we see eg: 0800 >(Hex) for ip. But per the statement quoted above it says that in the >802.3 header the length field specifies the number of bytes in the LLC >+ in the Data field. Now the LLC header I think is the SSAP and the >DSAP which are 1 byte each but adding the Data portion would be well >over the 2 bytes. Confused as to how it would store this. It's a total size. The LLC header is either constant length or contains additional size information (I don't recall which at the moment.) | ||||||||||||||||
|
Posted by newbie123 on August 1, 2006, 8:54 am
Please log in for more thread options
Hi Walter, can you please elaborate on what you mean when you say " the field is a length for the rest of the frame". Isn't it 1500 bytes and isn't that the max size of the ethernet frame including data etc. Data can be about 1460 + TCP Header + IP Header = 1500. How can the total frame ever be above 1500. Thx Walter Roberson wrote: >
> >"In the 802.3 frame type, this two-byte field after the source address
> >is a length field specifying the number of bytes in the LLC and data > >fields. If these two bytes are greater than 05DC hex (1500 decimal), > >the frame is a Version 2 frame. >
> In other words, if the field is up to 1500 then this frame is > a 802.3 frame, and the field is a length for the rest of the frame. > If the filed is more than 1500 then the frame is an 802.2 frame and > the field has frame type information instead of a length. > > > >Now in the Ethernet 2 Frame the type field is 2 bytes and since I
> >believe that is the most common format on most LAN's we see eg: 0800 > >(Hex) for ip. But per the statement quoted above it says that in the > >802.3 header the length field specifies the number of bytes in the LLC > >+ in the Data field. Now the LLC header I think is the SSAP and the > >DSAP which are 1 byte each but adding the Data portion would be well > >over the 2 bytes. Confused as to how it would store this. >
> It's a total size. The LLC header is either constant length or > contains additional size information (I don't recall which at the > moment.) | ||||||||||||||||
|
Posted by anoop on July 28, 2006, 2:24 pm
Please log in for more thread options
newbie123 wrote: >
> This question is probably trivial to everyone else but I am unable to > understand so please don't flame just in case. > > Per the Ethernet FAQ it states that the difference between the frame > types is: > > "In the 802.3 frame type, ... Perhaps this page will answer your questions: http://www.geocities.com/billalexander/ethernet.html. It shows all of the frame formats very clearly. > Another question related to the same frame type is that in the FAQ and
> other places it gives 4 frame formats. Now when it says difference > between Ethernet 2 and 802.3 is it referring to the 802.3 novell 'raw' > or to the combination of the 802.2 LLC and the 802.2 SNAP frame type. I'm not sure what the FAQ is saying but if it's calling differences between Ethernet 2 and 802.3, it's probably referring to 802.3 as a combination of the all of them (since they are all 802.3 frames). If you have a specific context, post that - it would be easier to point out what they mean in that instance. Anoop | ||||||||||||||||
|
Posted by newbie123 on August 1, 2006, 9:13 am
Please log in for more thread options
Hi Anoop, Thanks for your reply. I was referring to the answer given in general to the question "what is the difference between Ethernet 2 and 802.3". Are they referring to just the 802.3 format or are they referring to 802.3 SNAP or 802.3 novell raw. Also when reading through the FAQ again and also looking at the different frame types specified in your link just had another question What is the 802.2 LLC? I mean that isn't a frame type. The Faq says that the 802.3 frame type was developed to be used with 802.2 LLC. The difference between the ethernet 2 and 802.3 Frame type with 802.2 LLC is the addition of the DSAP and SSAP. Just wondering why introduce the same field split into 2. The type field specifies the same information in the ethernet 2 format. The 802.3 SNAP makes more sense as it allows for future expansion since now you can specify the OUI and the protocol type and than have 256 protocols under each category and OUI. I know I guess I am asking way too many questions. Just trying to get a better understanding of the fundamentals since it is a grey area for me. Thanks for your help. anoop wrote: > newbie123 wrote:
> >
> > This question is probably trivial to everyone else but I am unable to > > understand so please don't flame just in case. > > > > Per the Ethernet FAQ it states that the difference between the frame > > types is: > > > > "In the 802.3 frame type, ... >
> Perhaps this page will answer your questions: > http://www.geocities.com/billalexander/ethernet.html. > It shows all of the frame formats very clearly. > > > Another question related to the same frame type is that in the FAQ and
> > other places it gives 4 frame formats. Now when it says difference > > between Ethernet 2 and 802.3 is it referring to the 802.3 novell 'raw' > > or to the combination of the 802.2 LLC and the 802.2 SNAP frame type. >
> I'm not sure what the FAQ is saying but if it's calling differences > between Ethernet 2 and 802.3, it's probably referring to 802.3 as > a combination of the all of them (since they are all 802.3 frames). > If you have a specific context, post that - it would be easier > to point out what they mean in that instance. > > Anoop | ||||||||||||||||
>is a length field specifying the number of bytes in the LLC and data
>fields. If these two bytes are greater than 05DC hex (1500 decimal),
>the frame is a Version 2 frame.